Science and Law
17th July 2013

Overcoming a Lack of Exposure Data in Your Next Toxic Tort Case

Nobody on site collected and recorded occupational or environmental data measuring air, soil, surface or ground water levels of possible chemical contaminants. Now you’re left with a big question mark: What level of exposure did the plaintiff actually experience?

Overcoming a Lack of Exposure Data in Your Next Toxic Tort Case

What do you do if you’re confronted with a plaintiff who alleges they were harmed by a certain exposure, but exposure data do not exist?

Nobody on site collected and recorded occupational or environmental data measuring air, soil, surface or ground water levels of possible chemical contaminants. Now you’re left with a big question mark: What level of exposure did the plaintiff actually experience?

Enter the scientist who begins the search for information that can shed some light on the exposure levels. The scientist will likely use the following approaches, depending on case-specific circumstances:

1.) Employ models to estimate past chemical exposure based on the amount of a chemical used in an operation or the size of a spill or release

2.) Research the scientific literature to uncover exposure data for a similar set of circumstances involving the specific agent or a suitable surrogate. For example, if the plaintiff is alleging injury from an airborne occupational exposure to a specific volatile organic compound (VOC) with no available data, the scientist could find airborne concentrations for a VOC with a similar vapor pressure. Based on the surrogate’s emissions rate and the spill volume in a room (for which the dimensions and ventilation rate are known), the scientist could then calculate an estimate of the airborne exposure to the specific VOC. The scientist would take into account the surrogate’s properties as well as the work area where the alleged exposure occurred.

3.) Enlist the help of an expert. The right expert will be highly proficient in conducting an exposure assessment to evaluate existing data and developing an action plan to deal with a lack of historical data. The type of expert required will depend on the nature of the exposure. Following are a few examples:

  • Airborne chemical exposure: industrial hygienist, air dispersion modeler.
  • Dispersion of soil particulates in air or volatilization of chemicals from soil to air: soil scientist, air dispersion modeler.
  • Surface water contamination resulting in ingestion, dermal contact, or inhalation: environmental scientist specializing in multimedia partitioning of chemicals from water to air and potentially air to water, or ecotoxicologists to assess data from fish or plants that may have been adversely affected.
  • Ground water contamination in which a chemical moves from soil, sediment, surface water to ground water and plume (portion of ground water containing the chemical) movement must be determined: hydrogeologist, geologist, industry-specific expert (e.g.; gas-drilling experts in the case of hydraulic fracturing contamination allegations).

To illustrate how an expert can provide key insight, let’s look at the third example, ground water contamination, more closely. A chemical agent does not distribute equally to all ground water in a given area. If the chemical was introduced to the ground water at point X and the plaintiff lives in the direction indicated by plume movement, we could expect past, present and future exposure to the chemical in the ground water if the plaintiff uses the ground water. Hydrogeologists can determine the likely levels of exposure based on the amount of the chemical introduced into the ground water, the rate of plume movement, the amount of ground water, and other factors. Geologists and drillers can play an important role in the process of defining the extent of the chemical contamination of the ground water by installing monitoring wells to determine the chemical concentration over time. These monitoring wells can provide current chemical concentrations and determine ongoing concentrations for future use.

If the scientific research and expert analysis indicate very low or no exposure to the chemical in question, the information will strengthen the defense’s case. But if the information supports the likelihood of a significant exposure, the defense may consider alternate strategies.

This article was co-authored by Peter Harnett, a certified industrial hygienist (CIH) who provides expertise in evaluation of environmental exposure assessments, consumer product health-based risk assessments, health and safety program development, toxicology assessments, occupational safety training programs, biosafety evaluations, compliance audits for laboratories and other workplace settings. Peter is the founding member of Counsel in Occupational and Environmental Health (COEH).

Did you like this post? We are here to help! Schedule a consult with one of our experts.

Just fill out the form bellow and we will contact you with more information.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
This article was authored by Peter Harnett, a certified industrial hygienist (CIH) who provides expertise in evaluation of environmental exposure assessments, consumer product health-based risk assessments, health and safety program development, toxicology assessments, occupational safety training programs, biosafety evaluations, compliance audits for laboratories and other workplace settings. Peter is the founding member of Counsel in Occupational and Environmental Health (COEH). – See more at: https://www.innovativescience.net/blog/bid/93351/Vinyl-Chloride-Train-Wreck-Safety-Assessment#sthash.0ohq1WsF.dpuf
This article was authored by Peter Harnett, a certified industrial hygienist (CIH) who provides expertise in evaluation of environmental exposure assessments, consumer product health-based risk assessments, health and safety program development, toxicology assessments, occupational safety training programs, biosafety evaluations, compliance audits for laboratories and other workplace settings. Peter is the founding member of Counsel in Occupational and Environmental Health (COEH). – See more at: https://www.innovativescience.net/blog/bid/93351/Vinyl-Chloride-Train-Wreck-Safety-Assessment#sthash.0ohq1WsF.dpuf

Recent Related Articles

Dr. David Schwartz’s IADC Presentation: The Use of Genetic Testing in the Courtroom [Download Slides]
15 July 2020
Dr. David Schwartz’s IADC Presentation: The Use of Genetic Testing in the Courtroom [Download Slides]

On Wednesday July 8, 2020, Dr. David Schwartz of Innovative Science Solutions presented at the IADC 2020 Virtual Annual Meeting on a panel titled The Use of Genetic Testing in the Courtroom. A complimentary copy of the panel presentation is now available for download. Read more

The Use of Genetic Testing in the Courtroom: Dr. David Schwartz will be Presenting at the IADC 2020 Virtual Annual Meeting
02 July 2020
The Use of Genetic Testing in the Courtroom: Dr. David Schwartz will be Presenting at the IADC 2020 Virtual Annual Meeting

Dr. David Schwartz of Innovative Science Solutions will be presenting at the IADC 2020 Virtual Annual Meeting on a panel titled The Use of Genetic Testing in the Courtroom. Read more

WEBINAR ANNOUNCEMENT: What’s in Those Genes?
12 June 2020
WEBINAR ANNOUNCEMENT: What’s in Those Genes?

Genetic Evidence Concerning Causation for Mesothelioma 16 June 2020 at 2pm Eastern Daylight Time. Read more

Talc and Asbestos Defendants Should Monitor and Utilize Published Studies Linking Mesothelioma to Genomic Causes
28 April 2020
Talc and Asbestos Defendants Should Monitor and Utilize Published Studies Linking Mesothelioma to Genomic Causes

Plaintiff experts having been asserting for decades that all mesotheliomas must be linked to some asbestos exposure. Indeed, this has led to the erroneous (but widespread) view that mesothelioma is a signature disease, only caused by asbestos exposure. Read more

Let’s work together

The journey to scientific and commercial success is often complex and always critical, if you are looking for an expert partner to help steer you to confident solutions, contact us today

Contact us